Accurate angle measurement

Printable View

Jan 28, 2017, 02:51 PM
mklotz

Accurate angle measurement

In a Tool Talk thread, I talked about the need to measure the angle of a planer gauge accurately...

http://www.homemadetools.net/forum/h...7175#post85187

While this has more to do with how to use the tools you have rather than the construction of a new tool, like my taper measurement method, I feel it's a tool in the conceptual sense of the word, hence its presence in the tool forum.

The basic idea of this method is to use a sine bar to "cancel out" the angle to be measured and, having done this, the stack height under the sinebar becomes an indirect, accurate measure of the angle in question.

As the photo shows, the object is placed on a sine bar in such a way that raising the end of the sine bar can make one side of the object horizontal.

How do we determine when it's horizontal? A DTI is swept across the top of the object; when it shows no change in value from one end of the object to the other the top of the object is parallel to the surface plate on which the work is done. A surface plate is essential; for this scheme to be accurate the surface must be flat and featureless.

The DTI is supported on one of my height gauges. The height gauge plays no part in the measurement; it's simply a convenient way to adjustably support the DTI and slide it over the surface plate.

https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/f...he/85264-1.jpg

Purists may note that I used an adjustable parallel rather than Jo blocks to create the stack for the sine bar. It's easier and the effect on accuracy is negligible.

So, what were the results?

After the DTI showed no slope of the gauge, the adjustable parallel miked to be 1.136" high. With the 2.5" sine bar I was using this translates into an angle of...

ang = arcsin (1.136/2.5) = 27.03 deg

That's only 0.01 deg = 0.6 arcmin difference from the value I obtained in the referenced thread using a no sinebar method of measurement.

You'll only rarely need to measure angles with this degree of accuracy but, should you need to, now you know how to do it.
Jan 28, 2017, 04:41 PM
Frank S

I was wondering it the angle could possibly have originated based off half of the Old British 55° Whitworth the 27.03° being quite close to 27.5°
Jan 31, 2017, 08:42 AM
mklotz

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frank S

I was wondering it the angle could possibly have originated based off half of the Old British 55° Whitworth the 27.03° being quite close to 27.5°

I doubt that an American manufacturer would be making anything to Whitworth standard.

If you read post #12 in my other thread on this subject...

http://www.homemadetools.net/forum/h...7175#post85187

you'll learn that there appears to be no consistency whatever among manufacturers regarding the angle they use. Thus my notion that the angle serves some measurement purpose seems to be just plain wrong.

I do find it interesting though that, by picking some useful angle, they could have, without cost to them, created a "feature" of their tool to trumpet over the competition in their advertising even if that feature was of dubious utility.
Jan 31, 2017, 07:04 PM
Toolmaker51

In light of variety, it probably was established by means of henway.
Jan 31, 2017, 09:47 PM
Frank S

Yep just how much does a henway anywayj
Feb 2, 2017, 07:54 AM
DIYer


Thanks mklotz! We've added your Angle Measurement Method to our Measuring and Marking category,
as well as to your builder page: mklotz's Homemade Tools. Your receipt:

<div id="blocks"> <div class="block b1 pngfix"> <div class="bimg"> <div> <a href="http://www.homemadetools.net/homemade-angle-measurement-method"> <img src="/uploads/164977/homemade-angle-measurement-method.jpeg"/> </a> </div> </div> <div class="head pngfix"></div> <div class="left pngfix"></div> <div class="right pngfix"></div> <div class="blockover b1 pngfix"> <div class="title"> <a href="http://www.homemadetools.net/homemade-angle-measurement-method">Angle Measurement Method</a> <span> by <a href="http://www.homemadetools.net/builder/mklotz_3">mklotz</a></span> </div> <div class="tags">tags: <a href='http://www.homemadetools.net/tag/angle'>angle</a>, <a href='http://www.homemadetools.net/tag/measurement'>measurement</a> </div> </div> </div> </div>
Feb 3, 2017, 11:05 AM
mklotz

As long as the picture showing the setup is there, I should mention that it is exactly the same setup used to calibrate a sinebar.

Normally, the roll-to-roll distance of a sinebar is some simple value. 2.5, 5 and 10 inches are common values; the one shown in the picture is 2.5. But the roll distance can be any value SO LONG AS WE KNOW WHAT IT IS. If you make your own sinebar or inherit one of unknown accuracy, you'll want to measure the roll distance so it can be used when setting the sinebar to a desired angle.

One tool is needed - an accurate angle plate. They typically come in the form of 30-60-90 or 45-45-90 triangles. Every serious metalworking hobbyist should have one, preferably both.

If we replace the part shown in the picture with the known-to-be-accurate 30-60-90 triangle and adjust the stack height so the hypotenuse of the plate is parallel to the surface plate, we will know that the angle of the sinebar is 30 degrees to the same accuracy as the triangle.

The sinebar equation is:

sin(A) = S / L

A = angle
S = stack height
L = roll-to-roll distance

Solving for L then yields

L = S / sin(30) = S / (1/2) = 2 * S

Once the L value is calculated, it's worth writing it on the bottom of the sinebar with a Sharpie.

Speaking of Sharpies, they now make paint pens...

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

which make a more permanent mark than the ordinary Sharpie marker. Since they don't make an ordinary one with white ink, the white paint pen is a boon. It's especially useful when marking dark metals.
Feb 3, 2017, 02:09 PM
PJs

Quote:

Originally Posted by mklotz

Normally, the roll-to-roll distance of a sinebar is some simple value. 2.5, 5 and 10 inches are common values; the one shown in the picture is 2.5. But the roll distance can be any value SO LONG AS WE KNOW WHAT IT IS. If you make your own sinebar or inherit one of unknown accuracy, you'll want to measure the roll distance so it can be used when setting the sinebar to a desired angle.

One tool is needed - an accurate angle plate. They typically come in the form of 30-60-90 or 45-45-90 triangles. Every serious metalworking hobbyist should have one, preferably both.

If we replace the part shown in the picture with the known-to-be-accurate 30-60-90 triangle and adjust the stack height so the hypotenuse of the plate is parallel to the surface plate, we will know that the angle of the sinebar is 30 degrees to the same accuracy as the triangle.

The sinebar equation is:

sin(A) = S / L

A = angle
S = stack height
L = roll-to-roll distance

Solving for L then yields

L = S / sin(30) = S / (1/2) = 2 * S

Once the L value is calculated, it's worth writing it on the bottom of the sinebar with a Sharpie.

Speaking of Sharpies, they now make paint pens...

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

which make a more permanent mark than the ordinary Sharpie marker. Since they don't make an ordinary one with white ink, the white paint pen is a boon. It's especially useful when marking dark metals.

Thanks Marv for this adjunct to your above and finding out exactly what you have or build. To me it's an excellent thing to do because of the difficulty in making these exact lengths. Even the big names in metrology spend considerable time on this aspect, which is part of the high cost of theirs. Being somewhat leery of imports after my experience, these tests and some math will tell you what you have as best as your equipment will let you.

Also thanks for the link to the Oil based pens from Sharpie...makes sense they would jump on the band wagon. Have you tried them? Added them to my want list. Agreed about a choice of white but find Yellow contrasts on a lot of backgrounds too...the key is contrast I believe. :hattip:
Feb 4, 2017, 08:43 AM
mklotz

Quote:

Originally Posted by PJs

Also thanks for the link to the Oil based pens from Sharpie...makes sense they would jump on the band wagon. Have you tried them? Added them to my want list. Agreed about a choice of white but find Yellow contrasts on a lot of backgrounds too...the key is contrast I believe. :hattip:

Yes, I bought the set of Sharpies pictured in the URL.

I have a bunch of those cheapy free screwdrivers from HF. I throw them in all my toolboxes and bags. Don't care if I wreck them through misuse and sometimes even drive screws with them. The problem is the slot and Phillips have identical handles. I don't like wasting time sorting through to find the style I want. I took the white Sharpie and drew straight lines on the slot drivers and crosses on the Phillips handles. The marks are on each side and on the top so, no matter how they're lying (or even stuck in tool bag side pockets) at least one of the marks is visible. Saves me a lot of frustration.

I've always been curious why Sharpie never made a conventional white marker. Before the paint pens I used the metallics, gold, silver and bronze, on dark materials. That works but white is more visible.

Yes, it's all about contrast. Yellow is arguably better than white. Millions of years of evolution have made the sensitivity of our retinas peak exactly at the peak output frequency of the sun and that's in the yellow part of the spectrum.
Feb 4, 2017, 09:07 AM
Ed ke6bnl

Quote:

Originally Posted by mklotz

Yes, I bought the set of Sharpies pictured in the URL.

I have a bunch of those cheapy free screwdrivers from HF. I throw them in all my toolboxes and bags. Don't care if I wreck them through misuse and sometimes even drive screws with them. The problem is the slot and Phillips have identical handles. I don't like wasting time sorting through to find the style I want. I took the white Sharpie and drew straight lines on the slot drivers and crosses on the Phillips handles. The marks are on each side and on the top so, no matter how they're lying (or even stuck in tool bag side pockets) at least one of the marks is visible. Saves me a lot of frustration.

I've always been curious why Sharpie never made a conventional white marker. Before the paint pens I used the metallics, gold, silver and bronze, on dark materials. That works but white is more visible.

Yes, it's all about contrast. Yellow is arguably better than white. Millions of years of evolution have made the sensitivity of our retinas peak exactly at the peak output frequency of the sun and that's in the yellow part of the spectrum.

I also have a lot of HF screw driver and use a hack saw to put an X or - on the top for the same reason, and I am going to start heating the shaft to remove the shaft from the plastic and use the handles for my files without the handle.
PS good write up and do like the idea of the parallels for the height of the sine bar.
Feb 4, 2017, 12:23 PM
PJs

Quote:

Originally Posted by mklotz

Yes, I bought the set of Sharpies pictured in the URL.

I've always been curious why Sharpie never made a conventional white marker. Before the paint pens I used the metallics, gold, silver and bronze, on dark materials. That works but white is more visible.

Yes, it's all about contrast. Yellow is arguably better than white. Millions of years of evolution have made the sensitivity of our retinas peak exactly at the peak output frequency of the sun and that's in the yellow part of the spectrum.

Great idea on the screw drivers and have done similar on nut drivers (infernal/metric)...although my Craftsman sets are two different colors, the imports don't seem to have that sense.

Don't want to veer your post too far off track but; what a fine point you brought up about the evolution of the the retina to the sun. I did some study on that a while back because of my graphic work with Pantone/CMYK,RGB,HSL, etc. I found it is a fact that we are now able to actually see more colors than we did even a hundred years ago let a lone 2000. Because my graphic monitor is calibrated regularly I find my self seemingly creating "New" colors (in a loose sense of the term) using the tools in Adobe to create CMYK shades in between the standards of Pantone. It's not these colors weren't there by frequency of reflected light, but to me the key is that elusive feeling that can be evoked by seeing them. Like you said the Yellow of the sun also reflects/evokes that warm and sustaining effect in our psyche. Thanks for sharing your terrific observation prowess!