Free 186 More Best Homemade Tools eBook:  
Get tool plans

User Tag List

Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 11

Thread: Tried to forge a blade out of a big file. Disaster struck

  1. #1
    Supporting Member anthonyget's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2019
    Location
    Kelmarsh, UK
    Posts
    89
    Thanks
    31
    Thanked 153 Times in 42 Posts

    anthonyget's Tools

    Tried to forge a blade out of a big file. Disaster struck

    I found a beautiful huge file in a salvage yard. Not good enough to use as a file so thought I would forge it into a Japanese Tanto.
    It was all going so well until... If anyone can tell me what I may have done wrong I'd be very grateful. Thanks in advance.


    186 More Best Homemade Tools eBook

  2. The Following User Says Thank You to anthonyget For This Useful Post:

    sossol (Sep 2, 2020)

  3. #2
    Supporting Member suther51's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2016
    Posts
    380
    Thanks
    212
    Thanked 153 Times in 116 Posts
    I admit, total shot in the dark here.

    Wet coal, hydrogen embrittalment??

    Hopefully those with much more knowledge than I on this will weigh in.

    2,000+ Tool Plans

  4. The Following User Says Thank You to suther51 For This Useful Post:

    anthonyget (Sep 2, 2020)

  5. #3
    CanBeDone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2019
    Posts
    43
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 38 Times in 18 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by anthonyget View Post
    I found a beautiful huge file in a salvage yard. Not good enough to use as a file so thought I would forge it into a Japanese Tanto.
    It was all going so well until... If anyone can tell me what I may have done wrong I'd be very grateful. Thanks in advance.
    There are several things you should have been done:
    1. Run your angle grinder over it and check the color of the sparks produced. If brightly yellow, it is a plain carbon or low alloy steel. If dark red, it is rich in chromium / nickel, and then you better know exactly what its chemical composition is, or follow slavishly the heat treatment / forging procedures prescribed for it.
    For a plain carbon or low alloy steel, guesswork is good enough - mostly. These you may treat as plain iron-carbon alloys, and the iron-carbon phase diagram tells you the whole story. If you cannot read a phase diagram, you are well advised to get a book and learn about it. Here I do only the very basics.
    Attachment 36514
    Since your raw material is a file, the sensible assumption is to consider steel with 0.8..1% carbon and thus you have ferritic steel. I am putting emphasis here on how the steel acts under observation by x-rays, ferritic meaning it's crystallographic structure is body-centered cubic. Ignore the phase descriptions given in the attached phase diagram, they refer to observations under a light microscope.
    If you do heat treatment to just soften the steel, stay below the A1 transition temperature, i.e. below 723oC. 500..600oC is a good choice. If you do want to go higher, all your steel must be hot enough to be in the γ (gamma) phase, also called austenite. If not, you will have problems with toughness / cracking later. Use of the magnetic transition temperature (A2 can give you guidance, but is no guarantee that your steel is fully austenitic. Small remainders have huge consequences for toughness / cracking. And if you want to do forging just below A1, i.e. what is commonly called thermomechanical treatment, you need huge deformations per blow. Hand forging in that temperature range is just calling for trouble.
    The most likely reason for the steel cracking is your prior heat treatment, and here not the maximum temperature obtained, but the time it was held there leading to excessive grain coarsening. The fracture pattern you are showing is consistent with that - if the steel did contain no grain refiners (Al, Nb, V).
    But if the steel was fine grained, and a metallurgical investigation would show that, it might also be due to copper, phosphorus or sulphur segregation to austenite grain boundaries. I doubt it, though, since it would require liquid on at least some grain boundaries - and for that the temperature is wrong.

  6. The Following User Says Thank You to CanBeDone For This Useful Post:

    anthonyget (Sep 2, 2020)

  7. #4
    Supporting Member anthonyget's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2019
    Location
    Kelmarsh, UK
    Posts
    89
    Thanks
    31
    Thanked 153 Times in 42 Posts

    anthonyget's Tools
    Thank you so much CanBeDone. Unfortunately I wasn't able to open your attachment however your comments are very much appreciated. I will bear all that in mind. I was worried I hadn't annealed it correctly. Thanks again.

  8. #5
    TheElderBrother's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2019
    Location
    The Land of Cotton
    Posts
    278
    Thanks
    170
    Thanked 98 Times in 70 Posts
    Yeah! What he said!

    (I hate it when I read a post about something I'm involved in, like knifemaking, and end up feeling like a total amateur...)

    Quote Originally Posted by CanBeDone View Post
    There are several things you should have been done:
    1. Run your angle grinder over it and check the color of the sparks produced. If brightly yellow, it is a plain carbon or low alloy steel. If dark red, it is rich in chromium / nickel, and then you better know exactly what its chemical composition is, or follow slavishly the heat treatment / forging procedures prescribed for it.
    For a plain carbon or low alloy steel, guesswork is good enough - mostly. These you may treat as plain iron-carbon alloys, and the iron-carbon phase diagram tells you the whole story. If you cannot read a phase diagram, you are well advised to get a book and learn about it. Here I do only the very basics.
    Attachment 36514
    Since your raw material is a file, the sensible assumption is to consider steel with 0.8..1% carbon and thus you have ferritic steel. I am putting emphasis here on how the steel acts under observation by x-rays, ferritic meaning it's crystallographic structure is body-centered cubic. Ignore the phase descriptions given in the attached phase diagram, they refer to observations under a light microscope.
    If you do heat treatment to just soften the steel, stay below the A1 transition temperature, i.e. below 723oC. 500..600oC is a good choice. If you do want to go higher, all your steel must be hot enough to be in the γ (gamma) phase, also called austenite. If not, you will have problems with toughness / cracking later. Use of the magnetic transition temperature (A2 can give you guidance, but is no guarantee that your steel is fully austenitic. Small remainders have huge consequences for toughness / cracking. And if you want to do forging just below A1, i.e. what is commonly called thermomechanical treatment, you need huge deformations per blow. Hand forging in that temperature range is just calling for trouble.
    The most likely reason for the steel cracking is your prior heat treatment, and here not the maximum temperature obtained, but the time it was held there leading to excessive grain coarsening. The fracture pattern you are showing is consistent with that - if the steel did contain no grain refiners (Al, Nb, V).
    But if the steel was fine grained, and a metallurgical investigation would show that, it might also be due to copper, phosphorus or sulphur segregation to austenite grain boundaries. I doubt it, though, since it would require liquid on at least some grain boundaries - and for that the temperature is wrong.

  9. The Following User Says Thank You to TheElderBrother For This Useful Post:

    anthonyget (Sep 2, 2020)

  10. #6
    Supporting Member anthonyget's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2019
    Location
    Kelmarsh, UK
    Posts
    89
    Thanks
    31
    Thanked 153 Times in 42 Posts

    anthonyget's Tools
    Quote Originally Posted by TheElderBrother View Post
    Yeah! What he said!

    (I hate it when I read a post about something I'm involved in, like knifemaking, and end up feeling like a total amateur...)

    How do you think I feel.

  11. #7
    Supporting Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2016
    Posts
    1,113
    Thanks
    25
    Thanked 347 Times in 244 Posts

    old kodger's Tools
    I'm not a forging guru, but I had the same thing happen to a piece of, what was known then (1961) as S90 hexagonal bar 1" a.f. In the process of drawing it out to make a cold chisel, the end cracked resulting in a much shorter chisel. When I enquired of the heat treating specialist in the factory complex "why?", his comment was that it wasn't hot enough when I was hammering it.

  12. #8
    Supporting Member anthonyget's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2019
    Location
    Kelmarsh, UK
    Posts
    89
    Thanks
    31
    Thanked 153 Times in 42 Posts

    anthonyget's Tools
    Quote Originally Posted by old kodger View Post
    I'm not a forging guru, but I had the same thing happen to a piece of, what was known then (1961) as S90 hexagonal bar 1" a.f. In the process of drawing it out to make a cold chisel, the end cracked resulting in a much shorter chisel. When I enquired of the heat treating specialist in the factory complex "why?", his comment was that it wasn't hot enough when I was hammering it.
    Thanks so much for taking the time.
    I don't think it is that. I checked the video and it was hot enough. I think I made a mistake in the annealing process. You might be right, but not on that heat. I might have hammered it too hard on a previous heat that wasn't hot enough and caused the crack later. Very frustrating but I really appreciate your input.

  13. #9
    Supporting Member sossol's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    Lafayette, Indiana
    Posts
    550
    Thanks
    870
    Thanked 426 Times in 222 Posts

    sossol's Tools
    Above all else, what I like most about your videos is how you present your successes and failures with equal objectivity. I feel like I'm learning alongside you, albeit without all of the actual work.


    Neil

  14. The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to sossol For This Useful Post:

    anthonyget (Sep 3, 2020), high-side (Sep 2, 2020)

  15. #10
    Supporting Member anthonyget's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2019
    Location
    Kelmarsh, UK
    Posts
    89
    Thanks
    31
    Thanked 153 Times in 42 Posts

    anthonyget's Tools
    Quote Originally Posted by sossol View Post
    Above all else, what I like most about your videos is how you present your successes and failures with equal objectivity. I feel like I'm learning alongside you, albeit without all of the actual work.


    Neil
    Thanks so much Neil. Really appreciate your kind words.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •