Free 186 More Best Homemade Tools eBook:  
Get 2,000+ tool plans, full site access, and more.

User Tag List

Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Keep That Bandsaw Blade Tight!

  1. #1
    Supporting Member rgsparber's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Phoenix, AZ
    Posts
    1,278
    Thanks
    733
    Thanked 2,763 Times in 650 Posts

    rgsparber's Tools

    Keep That Bandsaw Blade Tight!

    When a bandsaw blade is not tight, you can get a meandering cut. I knew that. What I had not stopped to consider was exactly what was going on here. The result is this theory which awaits the considered eye of experts. It might be true but it might also be pure fiction.

    If you are interested, please see

    https://rick.sparber.org/SlackBlade.pdf

    Your comments are welcome. All of us are smarter than any one of us.


    Thanks,

    Rick

    186 More Best Homemade Tools eBook
    Rick

  2. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to rgsparber For This Useful Post:

    12L14 (Jul 31, 2019), Alan Purdy (May 15, 2019), Paul Jones (May 16, 2019), Seedtick (May 10, 2019), Steved53 (May 11, 2019), Toolmaker51 (May 11, 2019)

  3. #2
    Supporting Member Toolmaker51's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Location
    Midwest USA
    Posts
    5,330
    Thanks
    7,041
    Thanked 2,977 Times in 1,892 Posts

    Toolmaker51's Tools
    I agree. IIRC, 4 x 6's use 1/2" blades, economical but flexible. Because guides cannot run zero clearance and they are predetermined returning to periphery of the tilted [to cutting orientation] drive and tension wheel. Can't account why certain horizontal machines comply and others defy proper setup. We have 2 Kalamazoo's 40 years old, cut well regardless the variety of material fed.


    Vertical bands cut without change being wrapped around their wheels. Discounting worn raker blades that mis-cut because one side dulls, still guides are culprit. I haven't seen any machine company prepare better setup gauges than DoAll, literally put metal cutting bandsaws on the map.
    But if you want to hotrod one of many brands, Carter is the go to world wide.
    https://www.carterproducts.com/band-saw-products

    2000 Tool Plans
    Sincerely,
    Toolmaker51
    ...we'll learn more by wandering than searching...

  4. #3
    Supporting Member tonyfoale's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Location
    Spain
    Posts
    1,549
    Thanks
    679
    Thanked 2,627 Times in 705 Posts

    tonyfoale's Tools
    Rick,

    This is something that I know a little about. I have been trying to find the time to reply but I have been a bit busy.

    Firstly let me talk about a bandsaw without twisted blades - i.e. a vertical machine.
    There is a ton of info on the net about tensioning and tracking blades, most is wrong but a smaller proportion is sound. What follows will upset some people because nobody likes to be told that they have been doing it wrong. I would suggest that anyone with doubts should have a look at videos by Alex Snodgrass from Carter Products.

    Specifically I am talking about tracking setup. Most advice is to set the middle of the blade over the largest diameter part of the crowned rim. This works but relies on the guides to keep the blade straight because there is no natural directional stability in the travel of the blade through the workpiece
    A better way is to place the front part of the blade (just behind the teeth because the teeth area can support no tension) over the crown.

    It is obvious that the part of the blade over the crown will have the greatest tension. So in the case of setting the middle as the tightest we can see that the front and rear sections will be relatively loose because those areas travel over the smaller diameter of the crown wheel.
    On the otherhand if the leading edge of the blade is over the crown then all of the trailing part of the blade will be looser.

    So what, you might ask. It is a question of directional stability of the blade travel in the workpiece. The setup with the tight section at the front with the rest waving about behind is akin to an aircraft with a tail fin, that keeps it pointing straight. I have prepared a very short video simulating a section of a bandsaw blade with the tight section (represented by a stick in the video) at the blade front, middle and rear which clearly shows the effect that I am talking about. Translate that to a bandsaw and you'll see that if the leading edge is the tightest then the blade will have directional stability and shouldn't need guide for straight cuts. The case with the centre of the blade being tight has no preferred direction of cut and relies on the guides to hold the blade straight. If it is the rear of the blade that is over the crown then the system is directionally unstable, that is the blade will have a strong tendency to veer off course and give the guides a hard job to hold it straight.

    The video is in the following post from Jon.

    On my own saw I only need the thrust guides to cut a dead straight line, I only have the side guides mounted toward the rear only for doing curves. The first two pix shows the blade position on the crowned wheel and the others show the side guides at the rear.

    Keep That Bandsaw Blade Tight!-blade01.jpg Keep That Bandsaw Blade Tight!-blade02.jpg Click images for full size.

    Keep That Bandsaw Blade Tight!-guide01.jpg Keep That Bandsaw Blade Tight!-guide02.jpg

    The preceding relies on the assumption that the blade is tensioned enough. If it is loose then, even with the tracking set as suggested, we lose that tight area about which the blade will twist and so we lose the well defined axis of twist. This can be checked simply by twisting the blade with your fingers at various tensions and also at the three tracking positions in the video.

    So Rick, getting back to your observations. A horizontal saw has to have wide guides to maintain an accurate and well supported blade twist. However it is the length of the blade between the guides that is relavent to the cutting stability. For best performance you still need the area with greatest tension to be just behind (above) the teeth. It could be possible that the twist in the blade changes the tension distribution across the blade and so in any particular machine you may need to alter the tracking from simply setting the front over the crown. Only testing can determine that. Twisting the blade with fingers is a very good guide as to which part of the blade is tightest.

    As mentioned above you lose a lot of the directional stability with a slack blade.
    Last edited by tonyfoale; May 14, 2019 at 02:13 PM. Reason: Video location

  5. The Following 12 Users Say Thank You to tonyfoale For This Useful Post:

    Alan Purdy (May 15, 2019), Andyt (May 16, 2019), Jon (May 19, 2019), Ken Koch (May 15, 2019), olderdan (May 15, 2019), Scotsman Hosie (May 14, 2019), Seedtick (May 14, 2019), Steved53 (May 15, 2019), tbdl (May 20, 2019), Tenn (May 15, 2019), Toolmaker51 (Jun 7, 2019), Tule (May 20, 2019)

  6. #4
    Jon
    Jon is offline Jon has agreed the Seller's Terms of Service
    Administrator
    Supporting Member
    Jon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Colorado, USA
    Posts
    25,446
    Thanks
    7,925
    Thanked 38,616 Times in 11,283 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by tonyfoale View Post
    I have uploaded the video here, Bandsaw blade stabilitymaybe Jon can find a permanent home for it on this forum.
    Here we go:


  7. The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Jon For This Useful Post:

    Alan Purdy (May 15, 2019), olderdan (May 15, 2019), Scotsman Hosie (May 14, 2019), tonyfoale (May 15, 2019), Toolmaker51 (Jun 7, 2019), Tule (May 20, 2019)

  8. #5
    Supporting Member Toolmaker51's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2016
    Location
    Midwest USA
    Posts
    5,330
    Thanks
    7,041
    Thanked 2,977 Times in 1,892 Posts

    Toolmaker51's Tools
    I think Tony is better than well suited, for all kinds of topics. For example, blade tracking.
    There must be correlation in dissecting blade travel and as remote as it seems, being able to engineer successful road racing motorcycle frames. Steering head angles. Rake and trail. Wheel sizes. Wheel base. There are others, but those appear related to bandsaw adjustment.
    It's impossible to describe how much minds like that contribute to our little community.



    186 More Best Homemade Tools eBook
    Sincerely,
    Toolmaker51
    ...we'll learn more by wandering than searching...

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •