Opinion is no substitute for observation of actual performance, but thank you for noting that your critique is merely unsubstantiated opinion. You are certainly welcome to offer whatever opinions you might entertain.

If your conscience is OK with the dangerous advice you have posted, it shouldn't be. Simple strap winches as you advocated, having no means for preventing runaway cranks when the ratchet is reversed to pay out strap under load, can and have caused serious injury. Attention, rayh conscience: That was bad advice.

Be safe out there indeed!