-
Building collapses during construction - GIF
-
-
Wow, there was some lucky people walking away from that.
-
looks like the old bamboo scaffolding again
-
and to quote an ad for carpets in Australia "Mr Hart, what a mess"
-
So scary the things they try to do.
That scene is tragic to watch and more tragic for those who DID NOT get out of the mess. There were some who did not walk away, if they lived through that, they may had very little access to medical care and may have never walked again.
An even more scary to me ... what happens on the jobs where the scaffold does NOT collapse? They would have completed that concrete deck with the poorly mixed, over watered, porous, questionable aggregate concrete they were using.
Then you have to imagine, they just hired some more guys for pennies a day to clean up the mess, and used the same materials to do it all over again. Maybe adding a few poles more poles next time.
-
Quote:
Originally Posted by
hemmjo
So scary the things they try to do.
That scene is tragic to watch and more tragic for those who DID NOT get out of the mess. There were some who did not walk away, if they lived through that, they may had very little access to medical care and may have never walked again.
An even more scary to me ... what happens on the jobs where the scaffold does NOT collapse? They would have completed that concrete deck with the poorly mixed, over watered, porous, questionable aggregate concrete they were using.
Then you have to imagine, they just hired some more guys for pennies a day to clean up the mess, and used the same materials to do it all over again. Maybe adding a few poles more poles next time.
How do you know they were using "poorly mixed, over watered, porous, questionable aggregate concrete"? I didn’t see that mentioned anywhere?
-
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Radioman
How do you know they were using "poorly mixed, over watered, porous, questionable aggregate concrete"? I didn’t see that mentioned anywhere?
I do not know with 100% certainty. I do not know where the work site show is located. However I have been working with missions, building a church in Haiti and homes in the Dominican Republic, for 16 years. (My avatar is actually the logo of our mission) During this work I have tried to educate those I work with in better ways to build. They are HARD workers, but they have no way to learn proper, important ways to do things. I KNOW from experience it is common practice to use questionable aggregate, excessive water, inadequate mixing, no consolidation, as well as (I forgot to mention) improper curing conditions. It is very common to just let the concrete bake in the hot Caribbean sun.
The church that I help to build was one of VERY FEW buildings that did not collapse in the 2010 earthquake that devastated Haiti.
The horrific death toll, in excess of 230,000 souls perished, was partially due to poorly constructed buildings. Most all of which are constructed with poorly executed reinforced concrete. https://www.thebalance.com/haiti-ear...conomy-3305660
Attachment 30497
If you watch the video closely, specifically where the yellow arrow clearly shows the man's reflection in the water pooling on top of the concrete. If you watch the man with the shovel where the red arrow is, you can see the concrete dripping from his shovel.
I stand firmly behind my experience and observations.
-
Of the eight people I count that went down in the collapse I count seven that seem to have been lucky enough to be able to walk away.
-
I'm afraid third world conditions are common, no matter how tragic. Even with a partial infra-structure, it's not wide spread.
Yet the rulers, usually despots and dictators, are very comfortable. so there will likely always be third world countries.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ktiifeX7_A
-
Maybe this where the term 'Slapstick' came from.
-
It's not just in the third world, a lot of concrete works in the first world is now done by 'cheap' unskilled third world labour, the 11 floor University building opposite me concrete work, along with most of the ground works, has been done by cheap mostly migrant labour. The University building I'm in, built 10 years ago, had to have it's main poured staircase supported for 6 months as when they started to remove the form-work it started to slump, that was down to the aggregate not being properly washed.
