@mklotz . BTW. I brought this up recently and my son informed me this is Babylonian method, not Newtonian. I looked ut up. This method is also known as Heron's method. His detailed deccription goes back to 60 AD.
@mklotz . BTW. I brought this up recently and my son informed me this is Babylonian method, not Newtonian. I looked ut up. This method is also known as Heron's method. His detailed deccription goes back to 60 AD.
MeJasonT (Sep 11, 2020)
The derivation of Newton's method is generally done by using the definition of a derivative. Since Newton (and Leibniz) developed calculus the method probably came to be known by Newton's name.
The Babylonians and Heron had nothing like calculus so it's not clear how they stumbled upon the iteration. My guess was by trying various numerical methods or by numerically extending something that works without iteration for perfect squares.
Example:
Let 'n' be the square root of 'N'. Then N/n = n and (n + N/n) = 2 * n so:
n = (n + N/n) / 2
It's not a huge intellectual leap to think that, if n is close to the square root, then the result of the above calculation should produce a number closer to the true root, iow an iterator...
n2 = (n1 + N/n1) / 2
---
Regards, Marv
Smart phones are to people what laser pointers are to cats
Homo sapiens is a goal, not a definition
MeJasonT (Sep 11, 2020), Toolmaker51 (Sep 11, 2020)
holy crap, the worlds round - when were you going to tell me. Next you will say Pluto isnt a planet.
In the famous song title by Jellybean - im just visiting this planet
I missed the Apollo bus coming back from the moon so i had to wait for the next one, nobody said it ws the last bloody bus.
Last edited by MeJasonT; Sep 11, 2020 at 03:47 PM.
Citizen of the "New democratic" Republic of Britain, liberated from the EuroNation
When it comes to drill bits I prefer two size numerations well possibly a 3rd
Imperial decimal for smaller or critical sizes higher end millimeter grades since those you can buy in tenths of a MM from the tiny through as large as you want, and lastly a fractional set in 64ths You can forget those 1,2,3s and A,B,C sizes I have no use for them although I do have a set of both
Last edited by Frank S; Sep 14, 2020 at 02:41 PM.
Never try to tell me it can't be done
When I have to paint I use KBS products
MeJasonT (Sep 14, 2020)
I think we need to be careful here. I have no use for lots of things that others find useful, but that is no reason to forget them or dismiss their usefulness for others.
It is the, "I have no use for ....." mentality that makes some people (especially legislators) think that "if I don't need it, no one needs it".
I would have hoped that this discussion would have help us be more open with our thoughts.
There are currently 3 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 3 guests)
Bookmarks